Hello everyone!

It’s been a hot minute. If you follow me on Instagram you know things have been somewhat crazy for me lately. I hosted a creator networking workshop, Creators, Drinks, & Clinks, plus my mom visited, all while keeping up with school. But I am officially back full time (2-3 blog posts a week) and I am so excited! Today is my FIRST Holiday Gift Guide post for 2019! I meant to start this October 1st, but that did not work out. So now we’ll be on an expedited schedule to get these out for y’all ASAP.

But today’s gift guide is about gifts for Lilly Lovers! This was highly requested and I found some great items for y’all. This guide will include all budgets and even non-Lilly branded items. I know Lilly can be pricey, so I wanted to give some options that give that Lilly vibe without the price tag. You can check out my gift guides from last year HERE. But let’s get into it!

$20 & Under

Thimble of Love Crafts has a wide variety of keychains, I.D. tags, and so much more! She offers a ton of different Lilly patterns and some items can be customized with a monogram. Her Lilly items range from $4 for a pencil topper up to around $15 for an ID/badge holder. These items are great for stocking stuffers, teachers, or just a small gift if you need to buy for a group of people. She even has some Disney inspired Lilly items as well, which I really appreciate. She is super creative and has everything from bookmarks to Bath & Body Works hand sanitizer holders! And y’all know I love to support small business. I added some pictures of my favorite items below; click the picture to be taken to the item on her Etsy!


Beautickled was also in my gift guide last year! You can order from her through Instagram and she has something for every Lilly lover. She has tons of prints available – just shoot her a DM to see what she has in stock! Denise is incredibly talented and makes everything from scrunchies ($5) to crossbody bags ($45)  and Lilly packs (fanny packs – $40)! She also has a few items that are great for Disney Lilly lovers, like her new mouse muff ear covers ($12) and mouse ear scrunchies ($8). Plus she has other items like headbands and necklaces that you can see on her Instagram! This is a great option again as a stocking stuffer, a small gift, or a gift add on. I personally have a ton of scrunchies, headbands, and Lilly packs from her and love them. Shop small this holiday season!


Cora’s Den has so many great pieces for any jewelry lover on your list! Y’all know that all of my monogram necklaces come from her. She offers Lilly printed monogram necklaces as well as any color of the rainbow! So whether you want a specific print, or something that’ll match any Lilly, you can find something in her shop. I personally love any of the gold options to go with my Lilly! She even has a mouse head monogram that’s great for Disney lovers. And if you know a little bow wearer, she has some adorable bows that have an acrylic monogram on them! Everything she sells is totally customizable for color, chain length, font, etc and INCREDIBLY affordable. Click the pictures below to be taken to that listing!


Lilly Pulitzer has some great gifts under $20! I’ll put a few of my favorites down below. Click to shop!

Pencil Pouch -$14

Could be used for pencils or make brushes! Great gift for students or teachers.

Tumbler with Straw – $18

Pair with a $5 gift card to Starbucks or Dunkin’ for a great gift under $25!

Large Jar Candle – $20

Who doesn’t love candles? And when they’re done burning it they can reuse the jar!


$40 & Under

Caloosa Waterwear has some amazing pieces to match your Lilly! Their Florida design, pictured below, is my personal favorite and a no brainer. It comes in tanks ($28), their long sleeve ultra comfort shirt (moisture wicking – $36), and even accessories like tote bags ($32), water bottles ($20), and coasters ($15). Plus you can customize tees with a Florida city of your choice for a few dollars more. I love wearing mine and I always get compliments on it, not to mention it wicks away sweat which is great for working out (perfect with Luxletic) or for the year round Florida heat. They also have an amazing holiday collection that’s perfect to go with Lilly! I’m talking pineapples and flamingos y’all! They even have some of their designs on mugs! So treat yourself before the holiday season or get them as a gift for someone else. I also have a DISCOUNT CODE for y’all to save 20% off your entire purchase! Use code JAYME20 to save 20%! Another great way to shop small this holiday. Click to shop!

The Golden Spindle is a dream come true for Lilly Disney Lovers! She offers tees, tanks, and more for the entire family with the most darling Lilly Mickey heads on them. Items range between $27-$39. Men’s, dresses for little ones, and even pullovers are available. She offers free shipping on orders over $35 plus you can get a discount with code “THENORTHERNPREPSTER”! Click the pics below to shop!

Lilly Pulitzer offers some great gifts for under $40! I’ll link a few of my favorites down below. Click to shop!

Insulated Lunch Box – $30

Where was this when I was in high school? Great for students or teachers!

Travel Umbrella – $34

I LOVE my Lilly umbrella! It’s great quality and holds up in heavy wind.

Run Around Hat – $38

Not gonna lie… I have SO many of these hats, and I love them! Highly recommend!


$75 & Under

All of these items are directly from Lilly Pulitzer! Click the picture to shop!

Paradise Blanket – $58

This would make a great hostess gift! I high key really want one of these lol. Plus I love the print!


Resort Scarf – $68

Scarves are a great way to add Lilly into a fall/winter wardrobe, especially if you live up north.


Finn Top – $68

I absolutely LOVE Finn Tops! They’re so soft and cozy, and my sister loves the one I got her last year. If you have a larger budget these can be paired with Luxletic leggings and/or a run around hat! They also make these for girls. 


$125 & Under

Palm Beach Sandals are the staple shoes in my wardrobe, especially when styling Lilly! They come in any color you can imagine and they even have embroidered options that you can get a monogram on or one of their other embroidered designs (these cost a bit extra). These are on the pricier side but they hold up beautifully, are made in the USA, and they’re a piece the person will have for years! And I get not everyone can wear sandals year round but trust me, they will be appreciated! They even have options for kids. I personally recommend the Palm Beach Classic sandal in the color platinum, pictured below, that run for $117.

Lilly Pulitzer offers some great gifts for under $126! I’ll link a few of my favorites down below. Click to shop!

Bahia Backpack – $98

I was so excited to see that Lilly is doing backpacks! This would be a great gift for a college student or a little Lilly lover. Pair with the lunch box and pencil pouch for the ultimate gift!

Assouline Lilly Pulitzer Book – $85

This is a beautiful collector’s item and perfect for a hostess gift or the ultimate Lilly lover! I am dying to get my hands on one of these myself.

Skipper Popover – $98

You really can’t go wrong with a popover! They make these for both ladies and children and always have a wide assortment of prints available; they even have solid colored ones. This is a piece they can use year round and they’ll get great use out of it.


That wraps up this first gift guide! I hope you enjoyed it and got some ideas. Feel free to leave a comment down below with any questions or concerns and I’ll be sure to get back to you.

Thanks for reading!


Disclaimer: This is not a sponsored post and all opinions are my own. This blog post includes affiliate links and I may be compensated when items are purchased through those links.