• About Jayme
  • Partnerships
  • Press
  • Shop My LTK
  • Needlepoint Canvases
  • Contact
  • Nav Social Icons

  • Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer
  • All Blog Posts
  • Fashion
    • Spring & Summer
    • Fall & Winter
    • Lilly Pulitzer
  • Travel
    • Disney World
    • Disney Cruise
    • Disneyland
    • Palm Beach
    • Paris
    • Palm Beach Travel Guide
  • Lifestyle
    • Wedding Planning
    • Beauty
    • Fitness
    • Recipes
  • Home & Decor
    • Hosting & Parties
  • Gift Guides
  • About Jayme
  • Shop My LTK
  • Shop Needlepoint Canvases
  • Featured Press
  • Partnerships
  • Contact
  • Mobile Menu Widgets

    Connect

    Search

The Northern Prepster

The Northern Prepster

Lifestyle + Fashion Blogger | Pittsburgh, Palm Beach, and Disney World

  • Fashion
    • Spring & Summer
    • Fall & Winter
    • Lilly Pulitzer
  • Travel
    • Disney World
    • Disney Cruise
    • Disneyland
    • Paris
    • Palm Beach
    • Palm Beach Travel Guide
  • Lifestyle
    • Wedding Planning
    • Beauty
    • Fitness
    • Recipes
  • Home
    • Hosting & Parties
  • Gift Guides
  • All Posts

PLMystery Mailer Review

October 12, 2020 · In: Disney World, Fall & Winter, Fashion, Lifestyle

Today I wanted to share something fun I got in the mail this past week, as well as share my unbiased thoughts with you! As y’all probably know, I am a huge Disney fan and a Lilly lover, so many years ago I discovered Pretty Little Monograms. If you have never heard of them, they are a great small business specializing in all things Disney and preppy. They sell so many unique items for women, men, and kids – and they are always rotating their designs so there is something for everyone.

A while ago they started selling PLMystery Mailers, and I have definitely been curious. They come out with a different mailer each month, each of a different theme. It is NOT a subscription, which gives you the flexibility to just buy one or get one each month.

So let us dive into September’s PLMystery Mailer!

P.S. I didn’t want to spoil too much in my cover pic – so the shirt I am rocking is from Caloosa WaterWear – use code JAYME20 for a discount!

This month’s theme was none other than Halloween! They tend to do holiday mailers the month before the holiday, so you have some time to enjoy the pieces. Each mailer included multiple items – this number may vary based on the month, but it will tell you in the mailer description. But each mailer includes an item with an exclusive design from Pretty Little Monograms!

I paid $65 for my mailer, plus $3.71 in shipping. I believe it promised 4-5 items from either PLM or other small shops (the listing is no longer live and it differs from month to month and I can’t quite remember). I was also required to check a box stating I understood it would ship on 9/29 (since I ordered 9/1).

Here is what I got in my PLMystery Mailer!

  • An embroidered, personalized tee from PLM (I chose the size, style, and color – I had a choice between orange and purple) – $30 value
  • An embroidered hat from PLM – $25 value
  • A can cooler from PLM
  • A “Boo to You” button from Parkbound Buttons – $4 value
  • A mouse bat keychain from Oh So Fabulous – ~$12 value
  • Ghost earrings from Prep Obsessed – $10 value
  • A sticker sheet collab from Lucky Rabbit Supply Co. & PLM

The stars of the show were definitely the tee and hat – both of which are so fun! I was supposed to be going to WDW this month, and I was looking forward to rocking these there. Even though we are no longer going, these are pieces that are festive to wear at home as well! I like how they gave us an option with the shirt color. I could also choose between a women’s fitted or a unisex. I chose a unisex medium so I could wear it to lounge around in after Halloween. Some months they even offer other options for a higher price point – such as 1/4 zips or raincoats! Plus these items combined would be $55 – so that is most of the money I spent on this box!

The smaller items I got were also super fun. I truly love all of them! Again, such fun items to take to the parks or to celebrate with at home. All of these companies I had heard of, but I had only purchased from Prep Obsessed in the past. I feel like there is a good variety of stuff as well; there is really something for everyone! My favorite item would have to be the button, but I really love the earrings and keychain as well. While I couldn’t guess-timate values for the can cooler or sticker sheet, the other items total approximately $26 – that combined with the $55 from the other items is $81 total – which is awesome!

So what are my final thoughts? Is it worth it? In my opinion, yes! I was super satisfied; I think it is all super cute and fun for Halloween. I also think it is a great way to shop small, and discover new small shops you may love!

If you are interested in a PLMystery Mailer, October ones are currently on sale with the theme “Dots, Dots, Dots!” This one is only $49, but there are upgrade opportunities to receive other clothing pieces. This may be a great box to snag as a holiday gift for the Disney lover on your list. You get a good bang for your buck, plus it helps you discover other small shops you may not have tried! You can click HERE to shop Pretty Little Monograms’ website!

I hope y’all enjoyed this post and that it gave y’all some insight if you have been curious about the box. Happy shopping!

Cheers!

xoxo
Jayme

Disclaimer: This is not a sponsored post, all opinions are my own. Some links given are referral links.

By: Jayme · In: Disney World, Fall & Winter, Fashion, Lifestyle · Tagged: boo to you, Disney, Disney World, halloween, lucky rabbit supply co, monograms, oh so fabulous, parkbound buttons, plm, plmystery mailer, prep obsessed, preppy, pretty little monograms

you’ll also love

Last minute halloween costumesLast Minute Halloween Costumes 2025
summer Disney must-have'sMust-Have’s for Disney World Summer Vacation Trips
Walt Life BoxWalt Life Box Review + Discount Code!

Join the List

Stay up to date and receive the latest posts in your inbox.

Reader Interactions

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Next Post >

I Said “Yes” To The Dress! – Wedding Planning Diary No. 13

Primary Sidebar

About Me

About Me

Hi there! My name is Jayme.

I love sharing my travels, fashion finds, and so much more here on my blog. You can expect a preppy, quiet luxury flair to my content. If that sounds something you're interested in - you're in the right place!

Thanks for coming on this journey with me!

Read More

Connect

join the list

Never miss a post! Sign up to receive updates and join my subscribers to see what's new!

Search

email me

hello@thenorthernprepster.com

Follow Along

@thenorthernprepster

I’m so excited to use the St. Anne Diaper tote f I’m so excited to use the St. Anne Diaper tote from @barringtongifts 💕👶🏻 Thank you so much Barrington for the gift🫶🏼

#diaperbag #barringtongifts
Ready for our October Baby🎀👶🏻🎃 While I Ready for our October Baby🎀👶🏻🎃 While I’m not quite ready for a whole nursery reveal/tour - here’s some snaps of some details📸

Loving this bookshelf with all the trinkets we collected throughout our TTC journey from the past 3 years as well as our first pregnancy and this current one👼🏼🌈 

Had to add some pumpkins as decor for this month - obsessed with the custom one from @sarahslusherdesigns and the jack-o-lantern is @jellycat 🫶🏼

#nurseryinspo #babygirl #octoberbaby 

I ordered this pillow from @shoprooneyhome and I’m obsessed!💕 Beautiful quality and so many fabric and embroidery choices. My cousin (who was born only a few months after me) knitted us the sweetest blanket - something we’ll treasure forever🫶🏼 

I love the way the curtains look with the wallpaper🌸 This little stool is a Homegoods find from a while ago - and I never knew where I’d use it so I’m glad it found a home! Obsessed with our diaper bag that still needs packed😅

This needlepoint canvas from @lepointstudio was a labor of love for our girl - and I’m so happy with how it turned out💕 As you may be able to tell she already has a fully stocked @jellycat collection😅 The little brass bear piggy bank I found at an antique shop - I found the same one on Etsy that I linked on my LTK👏🏼

The chicest diaper changing station you’ll ever see🎀 We found the trinket box and tray while visiting family friends in NC at a secondhand store. They look absolutely perfect in the room🫶🏼 The bow cup is a surprising Target find - and I’ll always buy a cute cordless lamp, this one being from Homegoods💡
Soaking in some fall fun before it’s baby month🍂👶🏻
#fall #36weekspregnant
Some quick clips from our beautiful baby shower☔ Some quick clips from our beautiful baby shower☔️👶🏻 I couldn’t have asked for a better one and we felt so loved! 💕
Venue: @twelveoaksmansion 
Centerpieces: @thebluedaisyfloral 
Dessert Cart Rental: @partyonbutler 
Desserts: My Mom & Sister
Trunk: @petitekeep 
Name Banner: @evanoteco 
Decor & Faux Florals: Me💅🏽
A special thanks to our family and friends who helped us with set up and tear down - we couldn’t have done it without you✨
Our Blair Elizabeth💕 Her first name comes from Our Blair Elizabeth💕
Her first name comes from Disney Legend Mary Blair, one of Disney’s first female concept artists🎨 She worked on films such as Cinderella, Peter Pan, and Alice in Wonderland✨ After a break with Disney to focus on her own fine art, she returned when Walt gave her free reign of a ride being built for the 1964 World’s Fair - It’s A Small World🌎

Blair and I will share the middle name Elizabeth - that I also share with my older sister. Given to both of us after our paternal Grandmother💕

We can’t wait to meet her soon!🌈

#rainbowbaby #babygirl #disneybaby
Had the best day celebrating our girl💕 We love Had the best day celebrating our girl💕 We love you so much Blair Elizabeth✨
#babyshower

As Seen On

National Geographic TODAY Palm Beach Illustrated NBC News

Footer

On the Blog

  • Fashion
  • Travel
  • Lifestyle
  • Wedding Planning

More

  • About Jayme
  • Partnerships
  • Featured Press
  • Shop My LTK

Copyright © 2026 · All Rights Reserved.